We now have added "Informational Posts" which are tidbits of information that may come in handy at some point.
Showing posts with label cc-Recidivism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cc-Recidivism. Show all posts

Child Victim Selection and Sexual Recidivism

October 2015:

Child victim characteristics (e.g., having boy victims, having unrelated child victims) are well known to predict sexual recidivism among adult male offenders (Hanson & Bussiere, 1998; Hanson & Morton-Bourgon, 2005). This symposium involves three talks that extend this literature by looking more closely at child victim characteristics and sexual recidivism.

The first talk looks at the association between sexual victim choice polymorphism (having victims of different genders or age categories) and sexual recidivism in a large sample of clinically assessed sex offenders in Canada.

The second talk looks at the role of incest offending, including type of perpetrator-victim relationship, and sexual recidivism using the same clinical sample.

The third talk examines the concurrent and predictive validity of the revised Screening Scale for Pedophilic Interests (SSPI-2: boy victim; multiple child victims; young child victim; unrelated child victim; child pornography offending) in a sample of sex offenders referred as candidates for civil management in New York State. ..Source.. by Skye Stephens, Michael C. Seto, Alasdair M. Goodwill, and James M. Cantor

Construction and Validation of SRA-FV Need Assessment

December 2013:

Abstract:
This article describes the construction and testing of a newly designed instrument to assess psychological factors associated with increased rates of sexual recidivism. The new instrument (Structured Risk Assessment–Forensic Version or SRA-FV) was based on previous research using the SRA framework.

This article describes the results of testing SRA-FV with a large sample (N = 566) of sexual offenders being evaluated for an early civil commitment program. SRA-FV was found to significantly predict sexual recidivism for both child molesters and rapists and to have incremental predictive value relative to two widely used static actuarial instruments (Static-99R; Risk Matrix 2000/S). ..Source.. by David Thornton -and- Raymond A. Knight

Forensic use of the Static 99R: Part 3. Choosing a comparison group.

September 2012:

Abstract:
Although the developers of the Static 99R describe the “Selected for High Risk/Needs” comparison group as including offenders “referred for services at forensic psychiatric facilities, such as offenders referred as Mentally Disordered Sex Offenders, Sexually Violent Predators,” no persons involved in SVP proceedings are included in any of the 23 research samples that comprise the four Static 99R comparison groups. We compiled sexual recidivism base rate data from recent USA samples at various stages of the civil commitment process. Available data do not consistently support the use of the “Selected for High Risk/Needs” comparison group for persons involved in the civil commitment process. ..Continued.. by Gregory DeClue & Denis L. Zavodny

Most civilly detained sex offenders would not reoffend, study finds

7-21-2013 National:

Other new research finds further flaws with actuarial methods in forensic practice

At least three out of every four men being indefinitely detained as Sexually Violent Predators in Minnesota would never commit another sex crime if they were released.

That’s the conclusion of a new study by the chief researcher for the Department of Corrections in Minnesota, the state with the highest per capita rate of preventive detention in the United States.
--Study examined 105 sex offenders civilly committed between 2004 and 2006.

--MnSOST-3 used to estimate effects of civil commitment on sex offense recidivism.

--Estimated four-year sexual recidivism rate was 9 percent for civil commits.

--Civil commitment reduced four-year sexual recidivism rate by 12 percent.

--Estimated lifetime sexual recidivism rate was 28 percent.
Using special statistical procedures and a new actuarial instrument called the MnSOST-3 that is better calibrated to current recidivism rates, Grant Duwe estimated that the recidivism rate for civilly committed sex offenders -- if released -- would be between about 5 and 16 percent over four years, and about 18 percent over their lifetimes. Only two of the 600 men detained since Minnesota's law was enacted have been released, making hollow the law's promise of rehabilitation after treatment.

Duwe -- a criminologist and author of a book on the history of mass murder in the United States -- downplays the troubling Constitutional implications of this finding, focusing instead on the SVP law’s exorbitant costs and weak public safety benefits. He notes that "Three Strikes" laws, enacted in some U.S. states during the same time period as SVP laws based on a similar theory of selective incapacitation of the worst of the worst, have also not had a significant impact on crime rates.

The problem for the field of forensic psychology is that forensic risk assessment procedures have astronomical rates of false positives, or over-predictions of danger, and it is difficult to determine which small proportion of those predicted to reoffend would actually do so.

Minnesota has taken the lead in civilly detaining men with sex crime convictions, despite the state's only middling crime rates. Unlike in most U.S. states with SVP laws, sex offenders referred for possible detention are not entitled to a jury trial and, once detained, do not have a right to periodic reviews. Detention also varies greatly by county, so geographic locale can make the difference between a lifetime behind bars and a chance to move on with life after prison.

Ironically, as noted by other researchers, by the time an offender has done enough bad deeds to be flagged for civil commitment, his offending trajectory is often on the decline. Like other criminals, sex offenders tend to age out of criminality by their 40s, making endless incarceration both pointless and wasteful.

The study, To what extent does civil commitment reduce sexual recidivism? Estimating the selective incapacitation effects in Minnesota, is forthcoming from the Journal of Criminal Justice. ..Source.. by Karen Franklin, In the News

Focusing on sex offenders

2-2-2010 North Carolina:

CHAPEL HILL — The term "deviant sex offenders" might seem redundant. How could anyone who commits a sexual offense be anything but deviant?

In reaction to such sentiments, there has been a federal attempt since 2006 to create a policy that allows federal officials to civilly commit offenders deemed too sexually dangerous to release even

after they have served their federal prison terms. The feds' push for civil commitment authority was challenged and is now being weighed by the U.S. Supreme Court.

At least 20 states already have civil commitment laws in place, and although no such law exists in North Carolina there has been interest in one. The high court's ruling could potentially force our state to accept and commit sex offenders from federal prisons, a costly expense that according to different studies could range anywhere from $60,000 to nearly $139,000 per inmate each year.

If the court does not uphold this ruling, North Carolina could still pass its own state civil commitment law, following in the footsteps of states that already have such laws in place but have not produced evidence that there has been a drop in the rate of sex crimes as a result of such policies.

Recent research has now questioned the efficacy of policies designed to identify and intensely monitor sex offenders. In a 2008 study from New York State's Department of Corrections, rates of sex crimes were compared for the 10 years prior to the passage of Megan's law (sex offender registry) to the 10 years after the registry was put into effect. This study found that even after the passage of the registration law, there was no change in the rate of sex crimes because more than 96 percent of all sexual crimes are committed by first-time offenders.

In other words, the law had no effect on reducing the number of sexual assaults because less than 4 percent of these crimes were committed by repeat offenders. So although state and federal governments have spent billions of dollars to contain and monitor offenders in the community, these efforts have not reduced the number of victims who have suffered through the experience of a sexual assault, as they do not capture the range of individuals at risk of committing a sex crime.

Victims of sexual assault deserve better laws that will effectively protect them and others from similar experiences.

Unfortunately, somewhat lost in the current debate and lawsuit is the effort to classify those with a mental illness as a higher risk for committing a crime. Currently, federal authorities identify individuals according to those who have "been found to have a mental illness or abnormality that makes them likely to strike again if they are released."

But mental illness is a term used to describe a wide variety of mental conditions, and while there is some evidence that people with particular disorders are more likely to be aggressive, including sexually aggressive, this category is ill-defined in the current law and could be interpreted differently by individual therapists.

At most, it is estimated that clinicians can predict with 10 percent accuracy the risk level of an individual sex offender striking again. For those already working with individuals who struggle with the stigma of mental illness, there will now be added consequences and a new battle to fight: the message that all those who are mentally ill are also dangerous sexual predators.

In addition to increasing survivor services, our state and the federal government would be better served to focus resources on:

Evaluating the effectiveness of civil commitment laws to see if they reduce the rate of sexual crimes

Understanding the factors that lead an individual to commit such a crime

Evaluating effective treatment programs

Those who work within the field of sexual violence are eager to prevent such violence from occurring. The U.S. Supreme Court and North Carolina would be more effective in their efforts if they first identified the causes of these crimes and then identified policies and programs that effectively reduce them. Currently, efforts are under way that would center the focus only on a few individuals, leaving the vast majority of sex crimes unaddressed.

The victims of sexual violence deserve better, including government policies that work, rather than a false sense of hope that the victims and others are safer. ..Source.. by Melissa D. Grady who teaches at the UNC-Chapel Hill School of Social Work.

To what extent does civil commitment reduce sexual recidivism? Estimating the selective incapacitation effects in Minnesota

June 2013:

Abstract

Purpose
This study examines the selective incapacitation effects of civil commitment on sexual reoffending among 105 Minnesota sex offenders who were civilly committed between 2004 and 2006.

Methods
The Minnesota Sex Offender Screening Tool-3, a sexual recidivism risk assessment instrument, was used to estimate what the four-year sexual recidivism rate would have been for these offenders had they been released to the community. Integration of Survival with Quality of Life (iSQoL) software was used to extrapolate the survival curves over a 50-year period to develop a lifetime sexual recidivism estimate.

Results
If the 105 civilly committed sex offenders had been released to the community, an estimated nine percent would have been reconvicted of a new sex offense within four years. Civilly committing these offenders therefore likely reduced the overall four-year sexual recidivism rate by 12 percent. The results further suggest that if these offenders had been released to the community, an estimated 28 percent would be rearrested for another sex offense within their lifetime.

Conclusions
To better align the costs of civil commitment with its public safety benefits, states operating these programs should emphasize the use of intermediate alternatives in the community for a more positive return on investment.



Highlights

• Study examined 105 sex offenders civilly committed between 2004 and 2006.
• MnSOST-3 used to estimate effects of civil commitment on sex offense recidivism.
• Estimated four-year sexual recidivism rate was 9 percent for civil commits.
• Civil commitment reduced four-year sexual recidivism rate by 12 percent.
• Estimated lifetime sexual recidivism rate was 28 percent.

..Source.. by Grant Duwe

Minnesota Sex Offender Publications

January 2013:

An Outcome Evaluation of Minnesota Circles of Support and Accountability (MnCoSA) - September 2012 (Research in Brief)

An Outcome Evaluation of Minnesota Circles of Support and Accountability (MnCoSA) - September 2012 (Full Report)

The Minnesota Sex Offender Screening Tool-3.1 (MnSOST-3.1): An Update to the MnSOST-3 - November 2012

DOC Rationale for Using the MnSOST 3.1

The Impact of Prison-Based Treatment on Sex Offender Recidivism: Evidence From Minnesota - March 2010(Research in Brief)

The Impact of Prison-Based Treatment on Sex Offender Recidivism: Evidence From Minnesota - March 2010 (Full Report)

The Effects of Failure to Register on Sex Offender Recidivism - March 2010

Sex Offenders in Prison - January 2011

Megan's Law in Minnesota: The Impact of Community Notification on Sex Offender Recidivism - May 2008

Sex Offender Recidivism in Minnesota - April 200

Residential Proximity & Sex Offense Recidivism in Minnesota - April 2007

Governor’s Commission on Sex Offender Policy

Level Three Sex Offenders Residential Placement Issues - 2003 Legislative Report

Diagnosis of Substance Use Disorder Among Incarcerated Offenders – 2002 Annual Report 

Sex Offender Policy and Management Board Study Sex Offender Supervision Report (February 2000)

1999 Report to the Legislature of the Community Based Sex Offender Program Evaluation Project (October 1999)

Civil Commitment Study Group Report (January 1999)

1998 Report to the Legislature of the Community Based Sex Offender Program Evaluation Project (October 1998)

..Source..

Do Sexually Violent Predator Laws Violate Double Jeopardy and Substantive Due Process: An Empirical Inquiry

9-7-2012:

Abstract:
In Kansas v Hendricks, the Supreme Court held that it did not violate double jeopardy or substantive due process to commit a person indefinitely to a locked state-run facility after he had completed his maximum prison sentence. Although the state is barred from incarcerating such a person to condemn his past behavior or to deter future misbehavior, it may incapacitate him if he suffers from a mental illness that makes him likely to commit a new violent sex crime – characteristics the Supreme Court found to be true of so-called sexually violent predators (SVPs).

In this Article, we question a core empirical foundation for the Court’s holding – that SVPs are so extremely dangerous that they have a high likelihood of committing repeat acts of predatory sexual violence if they are not locked away. If SVPs are as dangerous as the Court asserts then we would expect to see an incapacitation effect – a negative impact on the incidence of sex crimes after passage of SVP laws. In conducting our analysis, we use original data that we gathered directly from states with SVP laws.

To examine whether the laws have had an impact on the incidence of forcible rape and sex-related homicide, we employ panel data on U.S. states for the last few decades. We also use data collected in the National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System (NCANDS) to examine the impact of SVP legislation on the incidence of non-fatal child sexual abuse. Finally, since underreporting poses problems in accurately measuring the incidence of sex crimes, we examine gonorrhea rates, a common proxy for the prevalence of sexual abuse. Our findings suggest that SVP laws have had no discernible impact on the incidence of sex crimes. These results imply that states could more effectively reduce sex crimes by allocating these resources elsewhere. More importantly, they challenge the only constitutionally permissible justification for SVP legislation. ..Source.. by Tamara Rice Lave, University of Miami, School of Law -and- Justin McCrary, University of California, Berkeley; National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER)

Sexual Predator Civil Commitment: A Comparison of Selected and Released Offenders

2004:

Abstract:
This study compared two groups of sex offenders who were considered for civil commitment under Florida’s Jimmy Ryce Act: Two hundred twenty-nine sex offenders who were recommended by forensic evaluators to be civilly committed and 221 sex offenders who were recommended for release.

It was hypothesized that selected offenders would be more likely to display risk factors for sex offense recidivism than those who did not meet criteria. Data analyses revealed that selected offenders, as a group, scored significantly higher on actuarial risk assessment instruments.

There were also significant differences between the groups on other risk factors that have been empirically correlated with sexual recidivism. Selected offenders had higher frequencies of paraphilia diagnoses and antisocial personality.

These findings supported the hypotheses and suggested that evaluators are correctly selecting for civil commitment those sex offenders who have a mental abnormality predisposing them to sexual violence and who are at higher risk for reoffense. by Levenson, J.S. (2004). Sexual predator civil commitment: A comparison of selected and released offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 48(6), 638-648.