We now have added "Informational Posts" which are tidbits of information that may come in handy at some point.
Showing posts with label 2002. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2002. Show all posts

Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 1994

2002:

Reports on the rearrest, reconviction, and reincarceration of former inmates who were tracked for 3 years after their release from prisons in 15 States in 1994. The former inmates represent two-thirds of all prisoners released in the United States that year. The report includes prisoner demographic characteristics (gender, race, Hispanic origin, and age), criminal record, types of offenses for which they were imprisoned, the effects of length of stay in prison on likelihood of rearrest, and comparisons with a study of prisoners released in 1983.

Highlights:
---Released prisoners with the highest rearrest rates were robbers (70.2%), burglars (74.0%), larcenists (74.6%), motor vehicle thieves (78.8%), those in prison for possessing or selling stolen property (77.4%), and those in prison for possessing, using, or selling illegal weapons (70.2%).

---Within 3 years, 2.5% of released rapists were arrested for another rape, and 1.2% of those who had served time for homicide were arrested for homicide.

---The 272,111 offenders discharged in 1994 had accumulated 4.1 million arrest charges before their most recent imprisonment and another 744,000 charges within 3 years of release.
..Source.. by Patrick A. Langan, Ph.D., David J. Levin, Ph.D.

Assessing the effect of Sex Offender Notification on Emotional, Cognitive, and Behavorial Reactions

2002:

ABSTRACT
Recent increases in sexual victimization rates for children, combined with the highly publicized tragedies of such victimizations, fostered public demands for legislatures to take stronger action against those who commit sexual and violent crimes against children. Legislative response to public demands took the form of sex offender registration and notification statutes. Sex offender notification statutes allow for community dissemination of information about an adjudicated sex offender. The purported goals of sex offender notification legislation are two-fold: (1) to reduce the risk of individual sexual victimization, by prompting protective behaviors; and (2) improve public safety through the surveillance and reporting of “risky” behaviors (e.g. conversing with children) exhibited by sex offenders. Very little is known, however, about how community members respond when they receive sex offender notification. The primary focus of this research is to assess whether the goals of sex offender notification are being achieved. This study also explores the effect of notification on perceived risk of victimization, and fear of victimization.

Survey data are derived from a purposive sample of 88 Hamilton County, Ohio, residents having received sex offender notification, and a comparison group of 148 Hamilton County residents who had not received notification. Analyses indicate that notified respondents were significantly more likely to report the risky/illegal actions of sex offenders subject to notification, and significantly more likely to engage in behavior to protect household members from victimization. Although notification is not a significant predictor of perceived risk of victimization, the direction of the relationship between notification and perceived risk is positive--indicating that notified respondents were more likely to perceive risk of victimization for themselves and household members. The relationship between notification and fear of victimization for household members is also positive. Contrary to prior research, however, the relationship between notification and fear of victimization for self is negative, indicating that respondents who had not received notification were more likely to fear victimization. ..Source.. A dissertation by Victoria Simpson Beck

Sex Offender Treatment Programs

2002:

INTRODUCTION


Over the years, public fear of sex offenders has led to serious misconceptions regarding sex offender treatment. The atrocious acts carried out by some sex offenders are very hard for the public to understand, and present society with complex challenges. Society often finds it easier to turn a blind eye to the crime, lock up the offender and throw away the key than attempt to address the challenge appropriately. This lack of public understanding toward sex offenders has created the myth that sex offenders cannot be treated, and therefore should never be returned to the community. This paper is intended to dispel the myth of the untreatable sex offender, and provide conclusive evidence that sex offender treatment is not only possible but to a large extent is successful in reducing the recidivism of sex offenders. First, the sex offender population in Canada must be examined so that we know what we are dealing with.


SEX OFFENDER TREATMENT
Although many community members believe that sex offenders cannot be treated, an increasing amount of support has been collected that attests to the success that can be achieved by treating sex offenders. In fact, Correctional Service of Canada has continually been implementing more sex offender treatment programs since it began offering sex offender treatment in 1973. Capacity for sex offender treatment increased from 200 in 1987 to over 1700 in 1995 (Blanchette, 1996). In addition, Correctional Service of Canada has recently “expanded and refined its programs for sexual offenders so that it now funds numerous institutional programs” (Marshall, 2000). The massive implementation of sex offender treatment programs by Correctional Service of Canada has put Canada at the forefront of research and knowledge about sex offender treatment, and many of the Canadian sex offender treatment programs illustrate promising results. Therefore, many offenders are able to receive adequate treatment that allows them to lead crime free lives upon release.

The success of sex offender treatment is evident when recidivism rates among treated sex offenders are compared to untreated sex offenders. For example, in one meta-analysis of treatment studies, Hall (1995) found that across several studies, treated offenders sexually recidivated at a rate of 19%, whereas untreated offenders sexually recidivated at a rate of 27% (as cited in Blanchette, 1996). This suggests that, overall, the treatment provided was able to produce an 8% reduction in the recurrence of sexual recidivism for treated sex offenders. This is a very promising result when it is considered that sex offenders often victimize more than one person, and there are usually multiple victims before an offender is caught. Therefore, even a small reduction in recidivism for sex offenders translates into a large reduction in the amount of sexual offences that occur (Blanchette, 1996). Given research such as this and the experience of the John Howard Society in working with sex offenders, the rest of this paper rests on the presumption that sex offenders are treatable and treatment programs do work. Therefore, it is important to determine what specific kinds of treatment methods work best for which sex offenders, so that they may all be treated effectively.

In order to lay the foundation for an examination of sex offender treatment, it is essential to review the academic research that has recently emerged about sex offender treatment. In most research studies, the term “sex offender” encompasses a wide range of offenders who have different treatment needs and different recidivism rates. The two most common types of sex offenders referred to in the research are child molesters who mainly victimize children, and rapists who mainly victimize adult women. Both sex offender types can be further sub-divided based on their relationship to the victim, as either incest offenders (familial relation) or non-incest offenders (not familial relation). Overall, research has shown that sexual recidivism for all sex offenders is quite low, with rates of only 10% to 15% five years after release (Hanson & Bussiere, 1998). However, researchers have found that different groups of sex offenders recidivate at varying rates.

One study using data from 10 follow up studies of adult male sex offenders (a combined sample of 4,673 offenders) divided sex offenders into three separate groups that are believed to be distinctly different from each other and, thus, require different treatments (Hanson, 2001). These three groups consisted of incest child molesters who victimize related children, rapists who victimize adult women, and non-incest child molesters who victimize unrelated children.

For the remainder of this paper: by JOHN HOWARD SOCIETY OF ALBERTA

Sex offender recidivism rates below expectations: more than 80% of sex offenders who underwent treatment did not reoffend

December 2002:

More than 80% of sex offenders who have undergone treatment do not reoffend within 15 years, according to preliminary results of a 15-year prospective study of 626 individuals reported at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.

The study did not examine the efficacy of various forms of treatment, but it did find that sexual offenders who were compliant with their treatment were less likely to reoffend than those who were noncompliant.

The results of the study were reported by Dr. Fred Berlin, who is director of the National Institute for the Study, Prevention, and Treatment of Sexual Trauma, Baltimore, and by Gerard J. McGlone. Ph.D., a clinical fellow at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.

The results are "a far cry from what people often think is occurring, particularly with a group of patients who are this serious, people with multiple prior offenses, people with pedophilia," Dr. Berlin said. "The notion that most of these people would quickly be back into trouble was simply not true."

The preliminary 15-year data update the group's 5-year study of the same individuals (Am. J. Forensic Psychiatry 12[3]:5-28, 1991). That study found an overall 9.7% recidivism rate.

The estimated rate of additional recidivism for the following 10 years was 9.3%, for a total of 19% over 15 years.

Both studies followed 626 individuals treated at the Johns Hopkins sexual disorders clinic between 1978 and 1990. Of those, 406 were pedophiles, 111 were exhibitionists, and 109 were characterized as "sexually aggressive," with most diagnosed as "paraphilic disorder not otherwise specified" or antisocial personality disorder.

The patients underwent a variety of treatments at the clinic, including individual, group, and family therapy. Approximately 40% of the patients received an-tiandrogenic drugs in an effort to lessen their sex drive.

Investigators examined three local and national databases for evidence of recidivism in the 5-year study.

Anyone who was charged with a sexual crime was included; conviction was not necessary.

For the 15-year follow-up, investigators have so far examined only Maryland state databases and have not yet examined national databases.

The 5-year study showed that 7.4% of pedophiles, 4.6% of sexual aggressives, and 23.4% of exhibitionists reoffended sexually The 15-year study added an additional 8.6% of pedophiles (total 16%), 10% of sexual aggressives (total 14.6%), and 10.8% of exhibitionists, (total 34.2%), the investigators said.

For the 15-year study, investigators have not yet reported recidivism rates for compliant vs. noncompliant patients. These data were reported at the 5-year follow-up.

For pedophiles, 2.9% of the treatment compliant and 11.1% of the noncompliant reoffended sexually For sexual aggressives, 2.8% of the compliant and 8.1% of the noncompliant reoffended sexually

And for exhibitionists, 12.5% of the compliant and 32.6% of the noncompliant reoffended sexually

On the issue of exhibitionists, Dr. Berlin observed, "Even with treatment, this is a very driven, compulsive disorder. The good news, though, is that in almost every instance where there was recidivism, it was a non-hands-on offense.

"These people were not recidivating by doing other things. With very few exceptions they were exposing. ... The more dangerous patients, the ones who had been sexually aggressive or who were pedophiles, had the lowest recidivism rates.

Nonsexual recidivism rates were considerably higher in all groups. At the 5-year follow-up, 9.2% of compliant pe dophiles and 26.2% of noncompliant pedophiles were charged with a nonsexual offense such as burglary. Among sexual aggressives, the rates were 14% of compliant patients and 29.7% of non-compliant patients. And among exhibitionists the rates were 10.4% of compliant patients and 4 1.9% of non compliant patients.

The study's results have important public policy implications, Dr. Berlin said.

Over the years, for example, legislatures in all 50 states and the District of Columbia have passed numerous laws involving the civil commitment, registration, and community notification of sexual offenders.

In addition, a federal law that took effect recently requires the states to notify the public about sexual offenders who are enrolled or working at college campuses.

The idea behind these registries and public notifications is the notion that sexual offenders are difficult to rehabilitate and have a particularly high rate of recidivism. (See related story page 5.)

But the data show that sexual offenders actually have a lower rate of recidivism that those who commit other kinds of crimes.

And some experts speculate that these new laws just might have the unintended consequence of actually increasing the risk of recidivism.

"We think that many of the people who seem to be doing well in our treatment program have done well because they could get jobs," Dr. Berlin said. "They could fit into their community.

"We now have these registries. Are [sexual offenders who have been punished and released going to be able to get housing? Are they going to be able to get work? Are we inadvertently actually going to make it more difficult for some of these people?"

..Source.. Clinical Psychiatry News, By Robert Finn

COPYRIGHT 2002 International Medical News Group
COPYRIGHT 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning


== Awaiting Confirmation of Study Type & Subjects ==
"According to a 1991 study of 626 patients conducted by Berlin's institute, five years after they had been treated through chemical castration fewer than ten percent had committed sexual offenses again. Of the most compliant patients, fewer than 5 percent committed new sexual acts. (Id.)"

Long-term Impact Evaluation of Specialized Sex Offender Probation Programs In Lake, DuPage and Winnebago Counties

2002:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Executive Summary reports on a study of the long-term impact of specialized sex offender probation programs in DuPage, Lake and Winnebago Counties. A previous study reported on the implementation and short-term impact of these three programs (Seng et al. 2000). The current study explores the impact of these programs comparing recidivism and treatment failure of sex offenders who participated in the specialized sex offender probation program (the grant sample) to recidivism and treatment failure of sex offenders on probation who were not part of the specialized program (the control sample). We obtained information about recidivism from Illinois State Police Rap Sheets supplemented with information from FBI criminal histories, violation of probation petitions, polygraph tests, and therapists’ bi-monthly treatment reports. Recidivism was defined as new arrests or self-reports of new offenses after the time that they were arrested for the offense that placed them on probation. Sexual recidivism was defined as any new sex crime except arrests for failure to register as a sex offender were not included. Violent recidivism was defined as any new violent or sex crime. General recidivism was defined as a new crime of any type, including misdemeanors such as driving while intoxicated, but other traffic offenses were not included.

The specialized programs, especially Lake County, increased its field surveillance and visits to sex offenders’ homes. This increased surveillance can have two opposing effects. First, increased surveillance may allow probation officers to detect a greater percentage of new crimes that sex offenders commit. For example, probation officers may discover child pornography on a sex offender’s home computer or may see a sex offender expose himself to a stranger during field surveillance. The higher detection hypothesis predicts that the specialized program will have a higher rate of sexual, violent, and general recidivism than the standard program. By contrast, the second way that increased surveillance may affect sex offenders is to deter them from committing additional crimes due to the fear of being caught and punishment. The deterrence hypothesis predicts that the specialized program will have a lower rate of sexual, violent, and general recidivism than the standard program. These two opposing effects can result in the specialized and standard probation programs having similar recidivism rates. Even if the two programs have identical recidivism rates, this finding does not mean that the specialized program had no impact because the higher detection effect can mask the deterrence effect. The evaluators, thus, are presented with a conundrum.

To overcome this conundrum, the evaluators used a deterrence conceptual framework to make predictions about which groups of sex offenders would be deterred or change from the intensive supervision of the specialized programs. Sex offenders can be deterred if they make a rational calculation of the cost (such as a new arrest) and benefits of committing a new crime before they commit the crime. We predicted that mentally ill sex offenders, psychopathic deviants, and sex offenders with sadistic or chronic aggression problems were not rational and thus should show higher rates of recidivism in the specialized program than in the standard program, which supports the higher detection hypothesis. We predicted that sex offenders interested in hands-off sexual offending often consider the cost and benefits of committing a sex crime before they commit the crime and should be deterred by the increased surveillance, which supports the deterrence hypothesis. Sex offenders that have already served a term of probation also may be deterred by the increased supervision because they realize that the consequences will be more severe if they are caught committing another crime. Sex offenders that have served a prior probation sentence may realize the severe consequence if they commit additional crimes and those on specialized probation may perceive a higher likelihood of getting caught if they commit a new offense; thus, the specialized program should deter sex offenders that have served prior probation and produce lower sexual, violent, and general recidivism rates than the standard program.

Our findings from the implementation study were that each county had successfully implemented a specialized sex offender probation program but in ways unique to each county. Our findings from this long-term impact study mirror this diversity. In general we found that the specialized sex offender program in each county had a positive impact on recidivism for certain groups of sex offenders, and were able to detect higher rates of recidivism for groups of offenders that do not make decisions in a rational manner (e.g., mentally ill offenders). The counties differed in what groups of offenders were affected by the increased surveillance and other conditions of the specialized programs.

This Executive Summary presents a comparison of the standard and specialized sex offender program and major findings for each county. We then discuss the overall implications of the study in general and make final recommendations about risk assessment instruments for child molesters. Our analyses focused on examining recidivism and treatment performances within each county with specific attention to differences between the control and grant samples. An additional and important focus was identifying groups of offenders in the total sample in each county who were at high risk of recidivism and treatment failure.

For the remainder of the study: by Loretta J. Stalans, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Criminal Justice, Loyola University and Magnus Seng, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Criminal Justice, Loyola University and Paul R. Yarnold, Ph.D., Research Professor of Medicine, Section of Emergency Medicine, Northwestern University Medical School

A 25-Year Follow-Up of Cognitive/Behavioral Therapy with 7,275 Sexual Offenders

2002:

Abstract:
Outcome data are presented, grouped into 5-year cohorts, for 7,275 sexual offenders entering a cognitive/behavioral treatment program. Assessment variables included treatment completion, self-admission of covert and/or overt deviant behaviors, the presence of deviant sexual arousal, or being recharged for any sexual crime (regardless of plea or conviction). It proved possible to follow 62% for the cohort at 5 years after initiating treatment, but follow-up completion rates decreased with time.

Outcomes were significantly different based on offender subtype, with child molesters and exhibitionists achieving better overall success than pedophiles or rapists. Prematurely terminating treatment was a strong indicator of committing a new sexual offense. Of interest was the general improvement of success rates over each successive 5-year period for many types of offenders.

Unfortunately, failure rates remained comparatively high for rapists (20%) and homosexual pedophiles (16%), regardless of when they were treated over the 25-year period. Implications for clinical practice and future research are drawn. ..more.. by Barry M. Maletzky, Oregon Health Sciences University -and- Cynthia Steinhauser, The Sexual Abuse Clinic